Three Quebec triathletes killed as pickup hits cyclists
Written by: Timothy Carlson
Date: Sat May 15 2010
Six cyclists were struck from behind by a pickup truck Friday at 10 AM on Highway 112 east of Montreal and three of them were fatally injured.
Sandra de la Garza, 36, of Saint-Bruno-de-Montarville; Lyn Duhamel, 39, of Boucherville; and Christine Deschamps, 44, of Brossard were killed. The other three riders were seriously injured, according to The Canadian Press.
The six cyclists were members of the Saint-Lambert Triathlon Club in south Montreal and were riding as part of a three-day training camp in Sherbrooke, preparing for Ironman Lake Placid this July.
Shortly before the crash the survivors had been riding two by two, a spokesman for the club, Eric Lemyre, told CBC News, but they returned to a single file formation because there was no paved shoulder. The cyclists were hit from behind by a pickup truck which was headed east on the four lane highway, Sgt. Claude Denis of the Sûreté du Québec told the Montreal Gazette.
The crash scene near Rougemont stretched more than 30 meters along Highway 112, with mangled bike frames, shoes, water bottles and a wristwatch covering the road, the Gazette reported.
Alcohol was not a factor, said Denis. The pickup truck driver, a volunteer firefighter in his 20s who lives in a nearby community, gave first aid to the victims, Denis said.
The accident was like a "bowling match," Jean Dessureault, one of the survivors, told CBC News. “I felt like I was flying and everyone around me was flying.” Dessureault, and the two other injured cyclists — both women — were released from hospital Friday afternoon. "We trained together all the time," Dessureault said. "It is horrible — they were young women in perfect health."
Police will investigate whether speed, driver distraction or mechanical problems played a role, Denis told the Montreal Gazette. “It was not raining so it appears weather was not a factor, said Denis. “It’s too early to say whether the driver will face criminal charges.”
Coroner André Dandavino, who is investigating the accident, told CBC News
he would investigate whether the driver of the truck was on cruise control at the time of the accident.
Dandavino told CBC News that the four lane road needs a paved shoulder so that cyclists can be safe.
Suzanne Lareau, president of cycling advocacy group Vélo Québec, told CBC News that the cyclists might have had more room if the shoulder had been paved. Under Quebec highway rules, any road travelled by more than 5,000 vehicles a day must have paved shoulders.
"I can't understand why on this part of the road, why the shoulder was not paved," Lareau told CBC News. Officials with Quebec's Transport Ministry said the province had planned to repave the section of the highway where the crash occurred, and would also pave the shoulders. Work is to start in the next few weeks, said ministry spokeswoman Julie Morin.
Several people in the area called that stretch of road particularly dangerous for cycling. The speed limit on the two-lane highway was 90 kilometres per hour, but residents said that was rarely respected. “It's very dangerous. The cars drive too fast,” Bruno Marcil, a cyclist who travels often along the road, told the Montreal Gazette.
Police said there was a bike path nearby but the path had paved and gravel parts, and the Saint-Lambert Triathlon Club riders' bicycles had thin road tires not designed for gravel.
The crash was reminiscent of an incident last summer in Ottawa when five cyclists were struck by a car whose driver was charged with hit and run. None of them died, but one of the riders was hospitalized for months.
Sandra de la Garza, 36, of Saint-Bruno-de-Montarville; Lyn Duhamel, 39, of Boucherville; and Christine Deschamps, 44, of Brossard were killed. The other three riders were seriously injured, according to The Canadian Press.
The six cyclists were members of the Saint-Lambert Triathlon Club in south Montreal and were riding as part of a three-day training camp in Sherbrooke, preparing for Ironman Lake Placid this July.
Shortly before the crash the survivors had been riding two by two, a spokesman for the club, Eric Lemyre, told CBC News, but they returned to a single file formation because there was no paved shoulder. The cyclists were hit from behind by a pickup truck which was headed east on the four lane highway, Sgt. Claude Denis of the Sûreté du Québec told the Montreal Gazette.
The crash scene near Rougemont stretched more than 30 meters along Highway 112, with mangled bike frames, shoes, water bottles and a wristwatch covering the road, the Gazette reported.
Alcohol was not a factor, said Denis. The pickup truck driver, a volunteer firefighter in his 20s who lives in a nearby community, gave first aid to the victims, Denis said.
The accident was like a "bowling match," Jean Dessureault, one of the survivors, told CBC News. “I felt like I was flying and everyone around me was flying.” Dessureault, and the two other injured cyclists — both women — were released from hospital Friday afternoon. "We trained together all the time," Dessureault said. "It is horrible — they were young women in perfect health."
Police will investigate whether speed, driver distraction or mechanical problems played a role, Denis told the Montreal Gazette. “It was not raining so it appears weather was not a factor, said Denis. “It’s too early to say whether the driver will face criminal charges.”
Coroner André Dandavino, who is investigating the accident, told CBC News
he would investigate whether the driver of the truck was on cruise control at the time of the accident.
Dandavino told CBC News that the four lane road needs a paved shoulder so that cyclists can be safe.
Suzanne Lareau, president of cycling advocacy group Vélo Québec, told CBC News that the cyclists might have had more room if the shoulder had been paved. Under Quebec highway rules, any road travelled by more than 5,000 vehicles a day must have paved shoulders.
"I can't understand why on this part of the road, why the shoulder was not paved," Lareau told CBC News. Officials with Quebec's Transport Ministry said the province had planned to repave the section of the highway where the crash occurred, and would also pave the shoulders. Work is to start in the next few weeks, said ministry spokeswoman Julie Morin.
Several people in the area called that stretch of road particularly dangerous for cycling. The speed limit on the two-lane highway was 90 kilometres per hour, but residents said that was rarely respected. “It's very dangerous. The cars drive too fast,” Bruno Marcil, a cyclist who travels often along the road, told the Montreal Gazette.
Police said there was a bike path nearby but the path had paved and gravel parts, and the Saint-Lambert Triathlon Club riders' bicycles had thin road tires not designed for gravel.
The crash was reminiscent of an incident last summer in Ottawa when five cyclists were struck by a car whose driver was charged with hit and run. None of them died, but one of the riders was hospitalized for months.
Articles related to this one
Apology not accepted
Tony Kornheiser of ESPN recently made some statements which had cyclists extremely upset and asking for the "head" of Kornheiser. After Lance Armstrong appeared on the Kornheiser radio show, the man apologized, but sports writer Sal Ruibal does not accept the apology. 3.21.10
Tony Kornheiser of ESPN recently made some statements which had cyclists extremely upset and asking for the "head" of Kornheiser. After Lance Armstrong appeared on the Kornheiser radio show, the man apologized, but sports writer Sal Ruibal does not accept the apology. 3.21.10
Berasategui hit by car in Mallorca
Virginia Berasategui, the 2009 Ironman Hawaii third place finisher and Wildflower champion had three teeth knocked when hit by a car while cycling in Mallorca. 2.16.10
Virginia Berasategui, the 2009 Ironman Hawaii third place finisher and Wildflower champion had three teeth knocked when hit by a car while cycling in Mallorca. 2.16.10
Comments
Perspective
Graham Dunn
Reviewed by: Graham Dunn, May 20 2010 12:09PM
A Ford F150 at 50 mph has the equivalent kinetic energy of the explosion of a third of a pound of TNT. I imagine that most people would not text while carrying around a quarter-stick of dynamite.
Bikes Should Be On the Road - Not on Paths Anyways
Reviewed by: Mike Sims, May 18 2010 5:28AM
I irritates me to no end to see these media people say a path was nearby. Paths are recreational paths, not places for fast moving group rides as this is completely dangerous to other pedestrians using these paths.
not trivial
Reviewed by: mimis, May 17 2010 10:36PM
you should've placed this tragic incident at the top of the page, makes more impact on cyclist readers than mr/mrsX winning -an unknown to many- race. [Editor's note: We agree with you as to the importance of this article's theme. The Slowtwitch front page builds in an automated fashion, however, according to an article's date and time of publication.]
cyclists - no respect
they keep blaming us!
Reviewed by: jac, May 16 2010 7:01AM
I will be glad when oil goes up considerably because mostly everyone (except for elite and don't care people) will out there with us biking away!!! Its soon to come.
Then we will be thanked for fighting for safer roads!
Quebec roadways are a mess! They are pot hole filled and neglected! Have to wonder where all the tax money is going!!! Lots of people complained about this piece of roadway, but not much was done! Hence, the city is somewhat responsible. Notice how they tried to "cover that up" by saying the cyclists should have been on some gravel railway pathway! That's not reasonable nor suitable. Anyhow, canada more and more is starting to remind me of a third world nation in its overall thinking. Its blame the lowest denominator in order to keep the Golliath alive. Damn shameful because we are wasting away a once great nation for the sake of human greed! Cyclists are not the problem! If this was a farmer in a slow moving tractor, they most likely would have gotten hit. If this was someone in a wheelchair, they most likely would have gotten hit. We are turning into hyper-impatient-panic-ignorant people in this nation. Partially due to the velocity of money (economy)- as the economy spins faster and faster people get panic like (read Shock Doctrine). And, we are careless due to our "freedoms" in some sense (we aren't really free though, we are dependent upon 3000lbs of metal to haul us around like a third leg). Anyhow, share the damn roads out there. We all pay for it (don't give me the crap that gas tax pays for it... oil is heavily subsidized! ). The debt we incure now (to future generations) is partially due to the overall costs of driving. Its costly to us all. In Americas, they say there are over 300000 incidents a year. If this was a diseasse, we'd stick millions at it. Instead we bail it out! shameful.
Then we will be thanked for fighting for safer roads!
Quebec roadways are a mess! They are pot hole filled and neglected! Have to wonder where all the tax money is going!!! Lots of people complained about this piece of roadway, but not much was done! Hence, the city is somewhat responsible. Notice how they tried to "cover that up" by saying the cyclists should have been on some gravel railway pathway! That's not reasonable nor suitable. Anyhow, canada more and more is starting to remind me of a third world nation in its overall thinking. Its blame the lowest denominator in order to keep the Golliath alive. Damn shameful because we are wasting away a once great nation for the sake of human greed! Cyclists are not the problem! If this was a farmer in a slow moving tractor, they most likely would have gotten hit. If this was someone in a wheelchair, they most likely would have gotten hit. We are turning into hyper-impatient-panic-ignorant people in this nation. Partially due to the velocity of money (economy)- as the economy spins faster and faster people get panic like (read Shock Doctrine). And, we are careless due to our "freedoms" in some sense (we aren't really free though, we are dependent upon 3000lbs of metal to haul us around like a third leg). Anyhow, share the damn roads out there. We all pay for it (don't give me the crap that gas tax pays for it... oil is heavily subsidized! ). The debt we incure now (to future generations) is partially due to the overall costs of driving. Its costly to us all. In Americas, they say there are over 300000 incidents a year. If this was a diseasse, we'd stick millions at it. Instead we bail it out! shameful.
