Skip to Content


Home > Training > Swimming > Your Best Freestyle Technique

Your Best Freestyle Technique popular

Written by: Gary Hall, Sr.
Added: Sun Jan 30 2011


In life there are lumpers and splitters. Lumpers like to simplify everything, perhaps to a fault, while splitters like to differentiate everything down to the finest detail, perhaps to an obsession. Neither is necessarily right or wrong, but for the moment, to describe the act of performing freestyle, where admittedly, everyone appears to have a different stroke, I am going to be a lumper.

Mike Bottom, Head men’s swim coach at University of Michigan and former Head coach at The Race Club, was the first to describe three unique styles of freestyle; shoulder-driven, hip-driven and body-driven (DVD available at www.theraceclub.com). In body-driven freestyle, Mike associates this style with a straight-arm recovery, rotating the hips and shoulders more in unison. Seldom do we see endurance swimmers using a straight-arm recovery, so rather than split that into it’s own category, let’s focus on the other two.

First, let’s ignore the fact that there are two different ways of kicking, 6 beat (using 3 kicks per arm stroke) or 2 beat (one kick per arm stroke). Some swimmers combine these and use a 6 beat on one cycle, followed by a 2 beat on the next cycle. Although either kick can be used with either shoulder-driven or hip-driven technique, there are good reasons to use one or the other that I will explain.

Hip-driven freestyle, utilized by Ian Thorpe, Grant Hackett, Eric Vendt, Larsen Jensen, Kaitlin Sandeno, Libby Trickett (Lenton), is a slower-stroke-rate freestyle (typically 60 to 70 strokes per minute). The hand holds in front after the entry, before initiating the propulsive motion backward. The biggest advantage of the hip-driven technique is that the slower time of the arm pull cycle enables the swimmer to get a bigger hip turn, thereby generating a greater counter force to pull against. The result is a longer distance per stroke. Even though this technique can generate greater power per arm stroke, in order to be fast, one must couple it with a six beat kick….and hopefully a strong six beat kick.

Shoulder-driven freestyle, utilized by Peter Van den Hoogenband, Federica Pellegrini, Janet Evans, Nathan Adrian, Ryan Cochrane, Dave Davies is a faster-stroke-rate freestyle (typically 80 to 110 strokes per minute). It is characterized by a quicker catch of the entry hand and a quicker release, creating more arm strokes but with less time to rotate the hips. Therefore, not as much power is generated from each arm pull, but since there are so many more of them, the frequency can make up the difference. Usually the shoulder rotates more than the hips with this technique, thus the name. One can use either a six-beat or two-beat kick with endurance shoulder-driven freestyle. In sprinting, which is virtually all done with shoulder-driven technique, only a six-beat kick should be utilized.

There are increasing numbers of swimmers, particularly for middle distance swims (100, 200 and 400 meters) who draw on the advantages of both techniques and opt for a hybrid freestyle, using one arm with shoulder-driven technique and the other with hip- driven technique (Lochte, Phelps, Lezak, Biedermann, for example). Some refer to this technique as the gallop for the asymmetrical appearance from above. It also depends on good strong legs and requires breathing every cycle to the same side. But it can be used in open water if the legs are strong enough.

So which technique is right for you? Chances are, unless you grew up in a swimming pool and in spite of how strong your legs might be, you are not a good kicker. If that is the case, then using a hip-driven technique might feel very relaxing and smooth to you, but it is nothing more than a Sunday stroll in the pool. You really have three choices. You can continue to swim slow using this technique. You can develop a strong kick, which may take years of work and improved ankle flexibility. Or you can develop a shoulder-driven freestyle technique. The third choice may not be the easiest, but if you want to get faster, it may be the best.

Turning your arms over at 80 to 100 or more strokes per minute requires a different level of fitness, but it can be done. In fact, most of the world’s fastest endurance women swimmers use this technique and probably half of the men do, as well. You simply need to start training at a higher stroke rate to reach this level of fitness. One of the best tools out there for this is the Tempo trainer by Finis, which is a little metronome that fits under your cap. When training, you will need to set the frequency of the beep according to how long your sets are, but slowly and steadily you will build up to where you can sustain the same high stroke rate for a mile or longer in practice.

For most triathletes, I recommend this higher-stroke rate technique, with either a 2-beat kick or a soft 6-beat kick. You may be losing some speed and propulsion from saving your legs like this, but the high stroke rate should get you out of the water the same or faster than the hip-driven technique. Either way, you should more than make up for it with a better bike and run. Does this mean you shouldn’t worry about training your legs in the pool? Not at all. Don’t forget you still need lift and counter-force from your legs to help you swim faster. We will talk about the four functions of the legs next time.

Publisher's note: Gary Hall, Sr., is the Slowtwitch.com swim editor. He swam for the U.S. on three Olympic teams, earning three Olympic medals. The Halls (Gary Sr. & Jr.) became the first father/son team to each make three Olympic appearances. Gary Sr. operates The Race Club in the Florida Keys, where swimmers of all ages and abilities go for coaching, camps, video and individual instruction.

For more instructional videos, you can visit the Race Club website - TheRaceClub.net

  

Articles related to this one
The Great Running Debate
What constitutes good running form? Does good form lend itself to natural, or barefoot, or minimalist, running technology? What are the hallmarks of that technology? 1.31.11
Cam Dye swim paddle tips
2010 St. Anthony's Triathlon Champion Cameron Dye swam for the University of Iowa and shared a few thoughts about hand paddles. They are a great tool for swimming indeed, but are apparently often misunderstood and wrong sized. 2.26.11
Kicking is not only for propulsion
Most swimmers think of the legs as only providing some propulsion. The kick actually serves four different functions in the swimming stroke; propulsion, lift, stabilizing force, and sustain speed (inertia). 3.09.11
How To Pull Underwater
There are huge differences in how you can pull underwater with your arm; differences in power and differences in frontal drag. But, like so many aspects of swimming technique, the underwater pull involves compromise. The question is, which way is best? 4.11.11
A blueseventy theft in UK
An unmarked Mercedes Sprinter van loaded with custom blueseventy Helix wetsuits and various other items was stolen after the British Gas Great Swim in London and has disappeared. 7.08.11
Swim nomenclature
The community of swimmers brings its own lingo to the pool. Here's your guide to swimming nomenclature along with a bit of etiquette throw in, no charge. 8.22.14
Swimming Photo Gallery 1
Slowtwitch senior correspondent and photographer Timothy Carlson offers the first of three photo galleries devoted to swimming. 2.09.09
Propulsion in the water
You’ve probably heard the phrases "feel for the water" or "catch," and if you’ve watched the top swimmers you’ve probably noticed that their bodies seem to glide over the water. Well, they are doing just that. 4.17.02

Comments

Hours of Training 3 out of 5 stars

Reviewed by: Agnese, Aug 16 2011 8:50AM

Interesting points. However, you do mention that it would take a lot of time to build a good kick, but you never talk about how many hours of training one would need to keep up that high turnover... Amateur triathlete only has about 5 hours per week devoted to swim. Not enough to upkeep that kind of a fast turnover as shown in the video.

Quality 5 out of 5 stars

I'm very impressed

Reviewed by: John Blyth, Apr 20 2011 9:32AM

As a struggling middle-aged triathlete - and hugely inefficient swimmer - I've hunted down lots and lots of stuff about swimming. The clarity of these videos is on a new level for me, in terms of clarity. I wonder if Gary Hall Sr. might take a look at 'feel for the water' or 'catch'? If anyone can demonstrate these things once and for all it were he.

Comments on efficiency 2 out of 5 stars

Reviewed by: G Gonzales, Feb 5 2011 11:39PM

I agree. Mr Hall Sr's swimming credentials are impeccable but he should perhaps state whether he has ever tried riding for six hours then running a marathon after his swims, and if so does he truly find a higher cadence (in open water with a suit) to be more optimal.

Triathlon is not pool swimming 4 out of 5 stars

Reviewed by: B Henn, Feb 5 2011 11:50AM

This is a really good article and video, and may be very relevant to pool swimmers or those that race in non-wetsuit events. But I have to disagree with the suggestion that triathletes would benefit from shortening their stroke. Most triathlon events are wetsuit legal, which largely negates the need for such a strong kick to achieve an effective hip driven stroke. The efficiency of the hip driven stroke (in a wetsuit legal event) is most ideal in triathlon because the race is truly just beginning as you exit the water. In triathlon (particularly long course) efficiency is the key to a successful race. Increasing stroke cadence may still be an effective technique, but why wouldn't swimmers want to work to increase cadence and still swim hip driven (or front quadrant style), thus further increasing efficiency without having to achieve a "new level of fitness?" Perhaps this technique might be useful on the ITU circuit, but is it really ideal for most age groupers? [Publisher's note: I had similar thoughts to those you expressed above, but, more related to how wetsuits may alter the technique a swimmer chooses to employ. I'm having some new-model fullsuits sent to Gary Hall, Sr., and he promises to write a follow-up to his excellent article after spending some time in them. He then may have further instruction for us, depending on whether a swim is wetsuit legal or not - just note that with new swim temp rules for WTC events, it's likely we'll have more non-wetsuit swims than in times past.]

Love It 5 out of 5 stars

Reviewed by: Peanut Butter Wolf, Feb 2 2011 10:22AM

Great article! I never could get the long, smooth stroke style (a la Thorpe, Hackett, etc.) to work for me (I'm more of a Prilukov or Manaudou). This helps me rationalize my swim style while everyone tells me otherwise!

Read 11 comments