State of Tri Bike Service - 2
Written by: Greg Kopecky
Added: Mon Jul 08 2013
Let’s continue the discussion, shall we?
The second shop I consulted with was Hypercat Racing in Ventura, CA. Hypercat is a by-appointment specialty shop and fit studio. Over time, they have earned a reputation for expert setup of complicated bikes, brakes, cables, and everything else this article is concerned with. They’ll fix anything, but are dealers for Kestrel, Blue, Storck, Guru, Valdora, and BH. Responses from Hypercat were provided by their lead bike fitter, Phil Casanta.
I sent the same questions to both shops, and will organize their responses together.
1. Please give us the 'state of the business' when it comes to modern triathlon bikes and selling/servicing them - profitably.
Gear West: In regards to ‘super bikes’ (anything with a propriety brake and/or complicated internal cable routing), the selling and service time has increased, resulting in decreased profitability because margins on the bikes from manufactures has remained steady. Service time is the main driver in adding labor that goes into a sale and post-sale. For super bikes, the service time has doubled in general. Entry-level tri bikes with dual pivot brakes and simple internal cable routing are just as easy to work on as the original tri bikes.
2. Do you charge based on time or task?
Gear West: We switched to charging by time spent for anything with proprietary brakes, cable routing, and integrated aerobars. This doesn't just include tri bikes. There are some complicated road bikes now too.
It doesn’t stop with the mechanical items you mentioned - [brakes, cables, etc]. For almost every [electronic] or Di2 product, we have to do firmware updates to get them functioning properly.
Hypercat: Both. In most cases I have an idea, based on previous experience, as to how much time a given task will take me for a specific bike. I set a rate based on that previous experience, even if it takes me longer in the end due to some unforeseen issue. Here is an example of a common repair. Front derailleur cable replacement: Cervelo P2 $10-$25, BMC Time Machine $30-$50. With the BMC, I have to remove the crank set, rear wheel, an access plate, and possibly replace the housing as well. The range is due to what I am actually replacing and what aero bar system I am routing the cables through. If it is a complicated problem that is difficult to predict, I charge by the hour in 1/4 hour increments.
Gear West: Customers who bought the bike from us know what they’re getting into because we tell them about it ahead of time. We do get some grief from customers who bought a ‘super bike’ from another shop and then bring it to us for service. Our mechanics have a lot experience, so a person might special order a bike from his local shop and bring it in to us for fitting and service.
A lot of customers want to know what work is going to cost ahead of time. For example, ‘a brake adjustment is going to cost $10’. However, with super bikes, we can’t always do this because frame size, tire size, number of wheel sets, brake pad size, cable length, cable routing, etc, all affect how a brake will perform. Sometimes it's difficult to even give a time estimate. If everything goes perfect, it could turn out to be a normal adjustment for $10 or it could take two hours of fishing cables and testing two sets of wheels and optimizing one or the other. I think the worst case was $60 for a brake adjustment over multiple visits because the customer didn't like how the brake performed even at its best.
The frequency of service work for customers who are really picky has increased to maybe one extra visit per year over the life of the bike. But, we see all ‘super bike’ customers much more than normal tri bike customers in the first 3 months of ownership.
With triathletes – and I know this is a common generalization – I find that they tend to be a little less savvy on their day-to-day maintenance. When a client is in the studio I do my best to educate them on how to use lube, what lube to use, when to change tires, cables and the like. Better educated clients make for less unhappy clients down the road. The biggest trick is not getting them educated or even to agree with what you are espousing, but following up on the advice.
4. What are the top two or three things/gadgets a person can invest in that you feel make a significant performance difference on race day?
Gear West: If you don't have a tri bike, getting just a basic tri bike will make a big difference in speed. Race wheels make a difference, but they can cost about the same as a basic tri bike. Electronic is shifting is a favorite of everyone at the shop, but it is also as expensive a basic tri bike.
#1 - Bike fit, Bike fit, and bike fit
#2 - A knowledgeable mechanic
#3 - Training partners
From a mechanical side:
#1 - Low friction derailleur pulleys (top picks - Tiso full ceramic and Hawk Racing)
#2 - Low friction bottom bracket bearings (top picks - Enduro and Hawk Racing)
#3 - Cables, housings, and routing (top picks - Jagwire and Yokozuno)
#3 1/2 - Electronic shifting
-Most complicated bikes
-Off-brand carbon clinchers are something to stay away from
-We like basic water bottles over most of the hydration systems out there. I’ve been zip-tying a standard bottle cage between my aerobars for years
Hypercat: This is a very difficult question to answer as it has so many individual aspects – i.e. the type of rider we are speaking of, their experience level, the bike we are discussing, and so on. But here are three things that I feel - while being very cool aesthetically - are not a necessary or practical item for the average triathlete.
#1 - Fully integrated brake levers in the aero bars. The worst example is the old USE knife blade levers. Most [integrated] systems are a huge pain to change the brake cable housings, so here is a great example of a cost increase in the service department. It also means there are no new lever options down the road - which means no options for different hand shapes, brake caliper choices (cable pull rate), or electronic buttons.
#2 - Hidden rear brakes. While I generally like the look of hidden rear brakes, the cost of maintenance is much higher [than standard brakes]. Plus it is difficult to change brake pads for different rim types, and can be a huge nightmare if you run two different rim widths between racing and training wheels.
#3 - Hidden spoke nipples, especially on tubular aero rims. The cost of repair is much higher with a hidden nipple, plus you or your shop must own the tool. I have no less than 13 different brand-specific internal nipple tools currently in my shop. And with a tubular wheel there is no quick fix at the race for a spoke replacement or even a basic wheel true [because you must remove and re-glue the tire].
The verdict I'm seeing is this: Cost-of-ownership is going up - period. The manufacturers are saying it and the shops are saying it. Technology comes at a price - not only at the original point of purchase - but for years down the road. One might suggest learning to do repairs on your own (as a forever do-it-yourself guy, I'm all for it). However, there is an inherent hurdle: the more difficult the job, the less likely the weekend mechanic can successfully complete it. Similar to automotive service, some jobs require expensive tools. With multiplication of headset and bottom bracket standards, your expensive tools can become obsolete. Even for shops, the cost of owning every possible tool is a real concern.
Does this mean we should halt technological advances for bicycles? Ought we put the computers and CAD drawings away, and keep riding the same stuff forever?
I'll offer my two cents of common sense: Technology ain't stopping. However, I think we'd all be best served by not adopting every single new-fangled toy out there. We must pick the most important ones for ourselves that fit our personal cost/benefit equation. Me? I'm grumpier than twice my age (and three times as ugly), and I pick my equipment accordingly. Others can't wait to get their hands on the latest-and-greatest gear, and love every minute of it. Each must find their own moderation. My only hope is that manufacturers can empathize with those who do not necessarily want equipment that is expensive or difficult to own, and continue to offer a variety of options.
Our tech editor Greg Kopecky shows you a sample maintenance schedule for your triathlon or road bike. How often should you replace the chain, cables, cleats, and brake pads? For more, read on and you won't regret it. 9.07.13
We review the line of torque wrenches from Italy-based Effetto Mariposa. This company is known for their Caffelatex sealant, but also makes some very nice tools. 10.28.13
We look at the current state of triathlon bike service and repair. With new designs, integrated parts, and endless technology, how does the retailer prosper? 7.04.13
We take you through a step-by-step installation and bleed procedure for the Magura RT8 hydraulic rim brake. This revolutionary design is featured on bikes such as the Cervelo P5. 3.29.13